top of page

Badvertising: The Importance of Getting Your Ads to Spec

Writer: Scott Oldham
Scott Oldham
5 hours ago
3 min read
A billboard advertising groceries with a pixelated image of a woman holding a bag of groceries

While the health of print media rises and falls like waves in the ocean, there is one vital sign that shows steady decline: print design expertise. As fewer new designers embark on careers within print as a distinct specialty, the accumulated knowledge of best practices for print steadily fades away with each retirement. As a result, when ad firms need to produce campaigns with a print component — including magazine space — their designers often lack a basic understanding of print specifications, producing ads that may look stunning but fail in a few key measures when sent to the printer.


This should matter to every publisher; errors in ad materials will become your problem if A) your issue won’t rip properly because of faulty ad contents or B) your advertiser’s page prints incorrectly. Even if your contract indemnifies you against print mistakes due to errors in supplied materials (and it should), it’s bad business. Whether your advertiser blames their agency or you, your goal should be to forestall an unhappy ad experience in the first place.


Double-checking supplied ad files should be part of your regular workflow. Here are some common issues to look for:


  1. Spot colors. Though the use of spot colors, or additional plates, in magazine publishing is the exception rather than the rule, many designers still reach for their PANTONE palettes for color vibrancy and consistency across platforms. But when those spot colors show up in ads that are intended for ordinary 4-color processing, they can wreak havoc with color processing systems. Furthermore, when a spot color is converted to CMYK on the fly, the resulting color may not match the intended brand color that the advertiser — or their designer — intended. They should be given the opportunity to choose their own 4-color equivalent.

  2. Bleed. Designers who have never worked in printed media may have no experience with the concept of bleed and trim. In general, it’s necessary to supply a page with an extra .125” of additional artwork around the page margins — and we call it “bleed” for some reason — to avoid blank spaces if the page is unevenly trimmed at the printer. Many magazines routinely circumvent this problem by enlarging the faulty ad artwork to fill their bleed space. Frequently, however, that work-around introduces a problem where there wasn’t one before, namely…

  3. Safety. Any important text in a print ad, such as branding or contact information, needs to be kept about .25” from the page edges, also known as the “safety zone.” When ads are enlarged to account for the absence of bleed, other information moves that much closer to the page edge, increasing the risk of its being errantly trimmed.

  4. Resolution. Web designers inhabit a world in 72 dpi. Print designers operate at 300 dpi. While it’s fine to change artwork from 300 to 72 dpi, the process doesn’t work in the opposite direction. Low-resolution (72 dpi) artwork enlarged to 300 almost always looked fuzzy, or pixelated. Designers who grab logos and images from websites are usually playing a dangerous game of roulette, in which the odds of the assets looking terrible in print are stacked against them.


There’s more: over-saturated artwork, incorrect color spacing, multi-colored QR codes also abound. None of these is even remotely a problem online, which is why so many designers remain blissfully ignorant of the risks in print.


When one or more of these errors is uncovered, the advertiser should be given the opportunity to correct the issue, rather than undertaking repairs yourself or crossing your fingers and hoping for the best. After all, the advertiser is paying for the space. It’s your magazine but it’s their page, at least for the duration. Their bad ad file may not be your fault, but a little consideration can keep an advertiser from looking elsewhere to deploy their messaging.


Need to integrate ad file review into your workflow? Talk to Quarto Creative. We advise publishers on efficient processes and quality assurance. Reach out to contact@quartocreative.com.   

Comments


bottom of page